Irridescent shark, NOT for the home aquarium either....

Orion

Ultimate Fish
Moderator
Feb 10, 2003
5,803
3
38
Kentucky
www.thefishcave.net
#61
JAWS69 said:
They will only grow to the size of the tank.
This is only because the outside of the fish stops growing because there is no more room to grow. The internal organs continue to grow, and will eventualy kill the fish if something else doesn't kill it off sooner.
 

Oralacerta

Small Fish
Jul 5, 2006
17
0
0
Syracuse
#62
JAWS69 said:
They will only grow to the size of the tank. I saw one at my local fish store in a big tank and it was about the size of my arm. Then I had one in a 20g and it got about 8inch.
Which is also known as stunting....

Aquariums are meant to simulate the natural environment of a certain fish, and if it accomplishes that, the fish will live longer and sometimes grow larger than in the wild, because there aren't dangers to the fish (besides its owners ignorance and/or neglect). An aquarium is a controlled environment and therefore, if we know what we are doing, are dedicated, and knowledgeable about the animal we are keeping, it will do much better than it would in the wild.

I'm not worried about offending believers of the "a fish won't outgrow its tank" mantra- a fish can't and won't and therefore will die instead of living a natural life. An aquarium is a simulation of real life, not a torture chamber. If you can't give a difficult or large fish the right environment, go for something easy. Otherwise, don't perpetuate this awful myth that fish are magically convenient creatures that won't grow too big if you don't want them to.

For different Pangasius Catfish pictures: Go to planetcatfish.com and you will see that there are several sub-species of the Pangasius Catfish. That's why some pictures labled "Pangasius" may look like different fish.

Iridescent Sharks, Pangasius hypophthalmus, are bred commercially in ponds, and some of these pictures and similar ones are most likely of people fishing from stocked ponds:
PlanetCatfish :: Cat-eLog :: Pangasiidae :: Pangasius hypophthalmus


Maybe some of our fish would live longer than us if we kept them properly. Just like parrots. Some macaws live much longer than their owners, but that's only when they are given the right environment: a large enough cage, a varied diet, social interaction, etc. If you kept a macaw in a 2'x2' cage, it would die prematurely. The only difference there is the macaw reaches its full size in 3-4 months, therefore you won't physically stunt its growth, but with fish luckily stunting is an outward symptom that we are doing something wrong and we can try not to repeat our mistake.

I hope no one thinks I am being unnecessarily forceful with my opinions, but the health and happiness of living creatures, whether it be people, dogs, fish, etc. is incredibly important to me, and should be for anyone who decides to take on the responsibly of owning a pet. Fish are so misunderstood and disregarded as some sub-standard form of life that they are mistreated and tortured every day, often by well-meaning people.

We shouldn't look at stunting as a convenient tool.
 

Last edited:

Doomhed

Large Fish
Feb 11, 2003
687
0
0
39
Rhode Island
Visit site
#68
well i am glad to hear this i ran across a web site that has a petition going to stop walmart from selling fish i actually have posted a thread about this topic. if anyone is interested in signing the petition please email me. and to ID sharks i have two of them they reside in a 44 gallon and seem to be quite happy they reside with 3 angels and they all get along fine. but then i love my fish.
All the walmarts in my area have stopped selling non-Betta fishes. It has been that way for some time now. The only reason they can keep those alive is that I personally wrote their care information for the Bettas over 5 years ago when I worked for the company. I wish I was kidding. The department managers were supposed to print up my care information sheet and have them available for the customers for every Betta Purchased, but instead most of them tape them to the sides of the Tank setup and never give it out to the customer.

oh never mind, my clown loach killed him anyways...god i have a messed up fish tank..
Nature has a way of balancing its self without our intervention!