Here's a thought - How about an archive to store old threads that haven't been updated in a while?
Define the time (2 weeks, 4 weeks, etc...) and if there has been no new activity - move the thread to the archive.
The original sections could be maintained (Freshwater Beginner, General, Equipment, Plants...) but move the old, stagnant posts there. *Have them still accessible through "search". *
I get a little discouraged when I enter a topic and see there are 20 pages of threads. *
Just a comment...
you are still my favorite fishin' hole! *

*