The breeding pair were both black, I guess that doesn't mean one didn't have the pink gene in them. I guess I will have to wait until they mature a bit to really tell what is going on. After a week or so, I will sort through the remaining guys in the tank and find 5 or so that are pretty/healthy. The rest will be fed to Vinny and Jackie. From there, I will try to sex the remainders and keep one male and one female, hopefully. This is all my master plan, just hope it works for me.